Home

Debate

News

Documents

Official Statements

Global Day of Action on Caste

Comment

Urgent Appeals

Issue

Related Links

WCAR Diary

Points of View

Search the web site:
Print This Article
Latest Updates
Point of View - 2004-02-06

Contents
  • DYNAMIC ACTION GROUP

    and more...
  •  
    Stand-off Continues
    7-9-01, Asian Human Rights Commission

    This is the last official day of the Conference. The closing ceremony is supposed to be held now, but instead we are in the Main Drafting Committee, and the governments are about to try to adopt or remove the 61 outstanding paragraphs. Some of those outstanding are ready to be adopted, but there are a large number of paragraphs that are in a stand-off situation. These relate to Palestine, apology and reparations for slavery and the caste issue (Para 73). We are waiting to see what they will decide.....

    Well, more paragraphs were discussed, a few adopted, most sent off for further discussion. It now seems inevitable that we'll continue tomorrow. Para 73 has still not come up.

    Jyothi Raj has continued her fast through the night and into today. Nothing has passed her lips since the evening of the 5th and this afternoon she began to become a little delirious. Eventually she agreed to break the fast, having made a very convincing moral statement against the delaying tactics of the Indian government, who are now looking to simply push the paragraph into no-man's land so it may be dropped without due consideration.

    Meanwhile in the Draft Declaration working group, Canada has made a bold proposal for "list of victims" (PP16-17) which would enable discrimination on the basis of work and descent to be covered by the entire conference documentation. The paragraph currently stands at:

    Recognizing that racism occurs on grounds of ICERD and that such discrimination is often closely related to discrimination based on culture, nationality and language.

     

    Canada proposed the following alternative wording:

    Acknowledging that victims can also suffer multiple or aggravated discrimination based on other grounds that can include inter alia sex/gender, language, religion, political or other opinion, social origin, birth, disability, age, HIV/AIDS status or other health conditions, culture, social or economic status, nationality, sexual orientation, work or other status.

    This was supported by New Zealand, Australia and the Russian Federation, but opposed by Africa and Asia, who have instead proposed an even weaker version of the original:

    The World Conference recognizes that discrimination occurs on the grounds of ICERD and that victims can suffer multiple or aggravated forms of discrimination based on other related grounds.

    GRULAC supported this proposal also. Guatemala is to be convenor of informal consultations.

    Posted on 2001-09-20
     
    World Conference Against Racism @ Asian Legal Recources Centre
    For any suggestions, please email to the support@wcar.alrc.net.

    For the best viewing, please use Netscape 6.0/ Internet Explorer 5.0 or above.